Utahns aim to ‘Trump’ Bears Ears monument designation

Protesters demonstrate against the new Bears Ear National Monument in San Juan County. President Barack Obama expanded his environmental legacy in the final days of his presidency with national monument designations on lands in Utah and Nevada that have become flashpoints over use of public land in the U.S. West, Montecello, Utah, Dec. 29, 2016 | Photo by Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune via AP, St. George News

ST. GEORGE – In the wake of President Barrack Obama’s designating the Bears Ears National Monument Wednesday, Utah officials have vowed to use every means open to them to see the new monument undone. They are also looking to the next resident of the White House as a hopeful ally in this endeavor.

During a gathering held Thursday in San Juan County protesting the new monument, many signs with the phrase “Trump this Monument” were displayed and held high. Speakers at the event also repeated the phrase as they appealed to President-elect Donald Trump to aid in dismantling the unwanted monument.

San Juan County residents protest against the new Bears Ears National Monument, Montecello, Utah, Dec. 29, 2016 | Photo by Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune via AP, St. George News
San Juan County residents protest against the new Bears Ears National Monument, Montecello, Utah, Dec. 29, 2016 | Photo by Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune via AP, St. George News

Views differ on whether or not Trump can actually undo the creation of the monument once in office.

Christy Goldfuss, managing director of the White House Council on Environmental Quality, said the Antiquities Act that allows a president to create monuments does not give a president authority to undo a designation, a rule the courts have upheld. She acknowledged, though, that Congress could take action.

The Antiquities Act of 1906 authorizes the president “to declare by public proclamation historic landmarks, historic and prehistoric structures, and other objects of historic or scientific interest that are situated upon the lands owned or controlled by the Government of the United States to be national monuments.”

The Act was approved by Congress and used by then President Theodore Roosevelt to create the Devil’s Tower National Monument in Wyoming in 1906.

In Obama’s statement regarding the creation of the 1.35 million acre Bears Ears National Monument, the president said it is “to protect some of our country’s most important cultural treasures, including abundant rock art, archaeological sites, and lands considered sacred by Native American tribes.”

Read more: Utah Republicans bristle at Bears Ears National Monument designation

As reported by the Deseret News, Goldfuss told reporters the Obama administration isn’t worried about the backlash out of Utah and believes attempts to undo the new monument will be unsuccessful.

However, Conn Carroll, communications director for Sen. Mike Lee, told St. George News Thursday: “What has been done by executive power can be undone by executive power.”

San Juan County Commissioner Bruce Adams talks with Rob Bishop as they hold a press conference in reaction to the new Bears Ears National Monument, Montecello, Utah, Dec. 29, 2016 | Photo by Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune via AP, St. George News
San Juan County Commissioner Bruce Adams talks with Rob Bishop as they hold a press conference in reaction to the new Bears Ears National Monument, Montecello, Utah, Dec. 29, 2016 | Photo by Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune via AP, St. George News

While the Act may not expressly allow a president to simply undo a monument designation, it does empower the president the ability to make “modifications,” Carroll said.

“There’s nothing in the act that mandates or controls how much (a monument) can be changed,” he said.

If Trump wanted to, Carroll said, he could change the size of the Bear Ears Monument and shrink it considerably. Once done, Congress could come in and pass Bishop’s Public Lands Initiative which would protect part of Bears Ears as a national conservation area while opening other parts to local and economic development.

“That would functionally undo 99.9 percent of what Obama did,” Carroll said.

Taking this route is a potential way Lee and other Utah delegates hope to work with the incoming administration to undo the national monument.

File photo: Donald Trump, the then Republican presidential candidate in file photo, acknowledges the crowd before speaking at Macomb Community College, Warren, Michigan, Oct. 31, 2016 | (AP Photo by Carlos Osorio, File, St. George News
File photo: Donald Trump, the then Republican presidential candidate in file photo, acknowledges the crowd before speaking at Macomb Community College, Warren, Michigan, Oct. 31, 2016 | AP Photo by Carlos Osorio, File, St. George News

“We’re optimistic that the Trump administration will do the right thing and honor the wishes of the people of Utah,” Carroll said. “This monument is on sand. It’s very precarious and we should be optimistic it can be functionally undone.”

Other avenues Utah’s leaders and congressional delegation are likely to pursue moving forward include possible legislation and litigation.

Stewart has stated that he will use his position on the House Appropriations Committee to block funding to the new monument.

Sen. Orrin Hatch said Wednesday that he will meet with Rep. Ryan Zinke, R-Montana, Trump’s nominee for interior secretary, and discuss what may be done about reversing the monument designation.

“His responses will largely determine my support for his confirmation,” Hatch said.

In addition, Hatch and Lee will reintroduce legislation to make Utah exempt from future presidents’ use of the Antiquities Act to designate monuments. It would be similar to legislation passed in 1950 exempting Wyoming from the Antiquities Act and place the creation of any new monument in the hands of Congress.

There has also been talk among the congressional delegation of either seeking to repeal the Antiques Act or greatly restricting its use in the future.

Report continues below image.

mgk-bears-ears-proposal-maps-stgnews-1
Image courtesy of the Department of the Interior, St. George News

On Thursday, Chaffetz, who chairs the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, sent subpoenas to Interior Secretary Sally Jewell and Goldfuss demanding a document dump related to the Bears Ear National Monument designation going back to 2013.

In the letters, Chaffetz states concerns that the Obama administration stepped over federal procedures involving local stakeholders and proper environmental assessment.

File photo: In this file photo:, U.S. Interior Secretary Sally Jewell looks at the "Moonhouse" in McLoyd Canyon, near Blanding, Utah, during a tour to meet with proponents and opponents to the "Bears Ears" monument proposal. President Barack Obama designated two national monuments Wednesday, Dec. 28, at sites in Utah and Nevada that have become key flashpoints over use of public land in the U.S. West, Blanding, Utah, July 15, 2016 | AP Photo/Rick Bowmer, File, St. George News
File photo: U.S. Interior Secretary Sally Jewell looks at the “Moonhouse” in McLoyd Canyon, near Blanding, Utah, during a tour to meet with proponents and opponents to the “Bears Ears” monument proposal. President Barack Obama designated two national monuments Wednesday, Dec. 28, at sites in Utah and Nevada that have become key flashpoints over use of public land in the U.S. West, Blanding, Utah, July 15, 2016 | AP Photo by Rick Bowmer, File, St. George News

“(Obama’s) sweeping application of the Antiquities Act raises questions about the administration’s commitment to transparency and consultation with local stakeholders with respect to designating national monuments,” Chaffetz wrote.

He continued: “… The (National Environmental Policy Act) and (Federal Land Policy Management Act) processes provide for a more thoughtful determination, whereas the Antiquities Act was meant to be reserved for emergency scenarios.”

Previous attempts by the Oversight Committee to obtain information regarding the Obama administration’s process for using the Antiquities Act have thus far met with a limited response, Chaffetz wrote.

Jewell and Goldfuss have till Jan. 13, 2017, to produce the requested documents. Failure to do so will result in the committee’s “obtaining them through compulsory measures,” the letters state.

On the state level, Utah Attorney General Sean Reyes said his office has been working with members of the congressional delegation as well as county and state officials on a pending lawsuit in case the monument designation happened.

“The Antiquities Act was passed to protect archaeological sites from pillage by treasure hunters with narrow, focused designations of thousands of acres or only what was absolutely necessary,” Reyes said in a statement released Wednesday. “It has turned into a tool for the Executive Branch to bypass proper Congressional authority, to designate millions of acres at a time and far beyond what is necessary to preserve sacred sites.

“Rather than shut out local residents, the Administration should look for ways to strengthen schools, pave roads, and build the local economy. Instead, it rides roughshod over repeatedly expressed local concerns and exceeds the law’s scope as intended by Congress when it passed the Antiquities Act over a century ago.”

It remains to be seen what course the brewing war over Utah’s newest national monument may take once the president-elect takes office next month.

Associated Press writer Brady McCombs contributed to this report.

This photo provided by Patagonia in its press release applauding the designation of Bears Ears National Monument Dec. 28, 2016, shows the Cedar Mesa region of the monument. In its release, Patagonia CEO Rose Marciano said, "In protecting Bears Ears, the president recognizes the leadership and historic vision of the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition representing five tribes, and the strong grassroots support from climbers and conservation groups. We are witnessing the power of community activism, and we thank President Obama for listening and taking action.” Southeast Utah, date not specified | Photo courtesy of Patagonia, St. George News
This photo provided by Patagonia in its press release applauding the designation of Bears Ears National Monument Dec. 28, 2016, shows the Cedar Mesa region of the monument. In its release, Patagonia CEO Rose Marciano said, “In protecting Bears Ears, the president recognizes the leadership and historic vision of the Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition representing five tribes, and the strong grassroots support from climbers and conservation groups. We are witnessing the power of community activism, and we thank President Obama for listening and taking action.” Southeast Utah, date not specified | Photo courtesy of Patagonia, St. George News

Email: mkessler@stgnews.com

Twitter: @MoriKessler

Copyright St. George News, SaintGeorgeUtah.com LLC, 2016, all rights reserved.

Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!

9 Comments

  • Gary December 31, 2016 at 7:19 am

    Now it’s open for all and not just a few cronies who want to develop and exploit the area.

  • anybody home December 31, 2016 at 10:51 am

    Love the picture of kids holding signs and wearing puzzled WTF looks on their little faces. Mormons are so good at using the kids to make their points…when the kids have no idea what they’re doing.

    • digger January 1, 2017 at 7:50 am

      Just what was goin thru my Mind. thank you.
      Using Children Still- So Sad.

  • comments December 31, 2016 at 1:51 pm

    To be fair, if I was a mormon-republican and stood to make hundreds of thousands $$$ in kickbacks from extraction interests, well who knows? Tempting to anyone, yes? In the end it’s all about money, and the use-it-up mentality of the mormon-republicans comes down to that and only that. That’s what being a politician is about. I wonder if a mormon-republican’s loyaty to the LDS church would come before their loyality to money and self-enrichment. i wonder…

  • Henry December 31, 2016 at 7:02 pm

    This is rich. So Mike Lee, who was the loudmouth leader of the failed coup against Donald Trump at the Republican Convention, is now begging for Trump to reverse this action? Pucker up and assume the position, Mikey.

  • dhamilton2002 January 1, 2017 at 12:58 am

    How one-sided can you get???? Other than a short mention of those in favor of the monument your entire article is about how our very-right-wing legislators intend to reverse the President’s designation. Maybe you could ask a few of those who fought for Bears Ears how they feel instead of parroting the alt-right philosophy of drill-baby-drill for the bucks. Very crappy reporting!!!!

  • .... January 1, 2017 at 2:56 am

    It’s amazing how stupid you really are

Leave a Reply